AUSTIN (Texas Tribune) — Mirroring other red states across the country, Texas Republicans are moving bills through the legislature that would limit what public school students are taught about the nation’s historical subjugation of people of color.
Two Texas bills would ban “critical race theory,” an academic discipline that views race as a social construct and examines how racism has shaped legal and social systems.
Decrying critical race theory has emerged as a common refrain among conservative Republicans nationwide, but the Texas legislation would go further by discouraging Texas students from discussing current events or controversial public policy issues.
“Texans reject critical race theory and other so-called ‘woke’ philosophies that maintain that one race or sex is inherently superior to another race or sex or that any individual, by virtue of his or her race or sex, is inherently racist, sexist or oppressive,” Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick said last week in a statement endorsing the legislation. “These divisive concepts have been inserted into curriculums around the state, but they have no place in Texas schools.”
But educators and social justice experts see the efforts as an attack on the state’s civic education curriculum at a time when students should be learning more, not less, about civics, social justice and history.
Last week, the Senate passed Senate Bill 2202, authored by Sen. Brandon Creighton, R-Conroe, which bans teaching that “one race or sex is inherently superior to another race or sex; (2) an individual, by virtue of his or her race or sex, is inherently racist, sexist, or oppressive, whether consciously or unconsciously.” Many Texas Republicans see critical race theory as a way to give students implicit or unconscious bias training, which Creighton’s bill seeks to prohibit. It passed the upper chamber 18-13, all its supporters white Republicans.
The state House is set to consider SB 2202’s sister bill, HB 3979, proposed by Rep. Steve Toth, R-The Woodlands, as early as this week.
Teachers’ organizations and education advocacy groups alike have mobilized to oppose both bills, and groups with no official stance toward critical race theory, like the Texas Civic Education Coalition, oppose the bills because they limit civics engagement and learning for students.
Beyond discouraging teachers from discussing current events and critical race theory, SB 2202 and HB 3979 also prohibit students from receiving class credit for participating in organizations that promote civic engagement and interest, according to the Texas chapter of the American Federation of Teachers. And the bills would ban school districts from receiving private funding for opportunities like social studies curriculum development, course materials and teacher training, as well. That provision means individual schools won’t be able to accept donations or materials for teaching the 1619 Project curriculum, a program developed by The New York Times Magazine that centers on critical race theory.
Many of the bill’s proponents have focused on playing to the popularity of banning critical race theory from Texas schools, Texas Civic Education Coalition leader Wendy May-Dreyer said. But few have mentioned the other provisions to diminish efforts to expand the state’s civic education curriculum, she added.
Texas AFT, the Texas State Teachers Association, Texas Educators Vote, the Texas Legislative Education Equity Coalition, the Texas Council for the Social Studies and The Education Trust have all expressed strong opposition to the bills, agreeing with May-Dreyer’s points while also going further to defend critical race theory.
“These bills try to ignore or downplay the racism, sexism and other injustices in our state’s and nation’s history, but students must be encouraged to fully explore and understand those injustices if Texas is to provide an equitable future for a rapidly diversifying population,” said Clay Robison, a public affairs specialist for TSTA.
In a statement to The Texas Tribune, Creighton defended his bill, arguing that Texas schools should emphasize “traditional history, focusing on the ideas that make our country great and the story of how our country has risen to meet those ideals.”
Across the country, many Republican-controlled state legislatures are considering similar bills to prohibit the teaching of critical race theory. Last week, Idaho became the first state to officially bar critical race theory from public schools and colleges after the governor signed the legislation, which the bills proposed in Texas closely mirror.
Also last week, the Louisiana House Education Committee discussed a similar bill authored by state Rep. Ray Garofalo. He withdrew the legislation after his colleagues criticized him for commenting on “the good” of slavery, according to The Washington Post.
“Not talking about racism and other forms of injustice won’t make them go away,” said Jonathan Feinstein, the Texas state director of The Education Trust. “This unnecessary bill — like others introduced across the country — prevents schools from proactively addressing harmful acts of discrimination, ties the hands of teachers rather than supporting them, and seeks to hold students back from grappling with and helping to solve real challenges facing our society.”
Experts said they expect the bill to reach the House floor at some point in the next three weeks.
“The prohibitions in the bill are broad and may be interpreted in ways that limit the learning, diversity and inclusion efforts already underway in schools across Texas,” said Zeph Capo, the president of Texas AFT. “The last thing we need is more overly broad ‘education’ legislation that will trap our state and school districts in expensive, needless litigation. Let teachers teach.”